Xlthos > Trade Notes

User Avatar
Brokerage Account
5 Day -8.64%
15 Day 10.44%
1 Month 7.49%
3 Month -0.88%
6 Month -16.94%
As of: 12/02/08

Member since: Jun 08

Sold 23 shares of AA at 27.23

Users Bought (30 Days) 9 (100%)
Users Sold (30 Days) 0 (0%)
Market Cap Loading...
52-Week High Loading...
52-Week Low Loading...
10 Day Volume Loading...
PE Loading...
EPS (Trailing 12 Mos.) Loading...
Transaction: Sold
Symbol: AA
Quantity: 23 shares
Price: $27.23
Value: $626.00
Stop Order: No @ $
Target Price: $

Over all I took a quite a bath.

Stock went down in early trading. I was too busy at work to watch. It was down about $0.46 before I had a chance to check. I sold ASAP at $27.23 and a -8.0354% loss on this trade.

A few things that went wrong:

Bought at 29.16 on a market order with no limit on Monday (1st mistake)

I did that because once I missed a good trade BECAUSE of a limit order that was too restrictive. I suppose I went to the opposite extreme.

I could not sell till next day because of my account type. (Circumstances, not an excuse)

Should have had a stop loss for Today but did not. (Amplified my loss - 2nd mistake)

            That was just plain stupid. (For some reason, I was just too busy.)

 

Questions:

Why did AA go down while rest of market went up yesterday? Partly because it gaped up but did not stay. Maybe it did not stay because profit takers guessed it would drift to close the gap - I suppose.

A limit order would have prevented purchasing at too high a price

Why didn't it go back up some today? I had hoped on a small bounce up to get out on.

Lesson:

Better to miss a trade that might make money because too restrictive of a limit order than to loose money by buying too high without one. Use limits and stops.

Anyone got any other ideas on what went wrong? I'd be glad to hear from

Add to del.icio.us Digg on Digg.com Submit to reddit.com
Bookmark It!

1 user tagged it: AA, stock, sell, xlthos
User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

MarkGrav

Member since: Sep 08

Trades 0
Trade Notes 0
Blog Posts 4
Software Engineer
Age: 40's
Providence, RI
MarkGrav

I got an idea what went wrong:

The trade on 9/5 looked ominous to me from a chart perspective. MACD ad just rolled over on you, and the trader MMA's (Short-terms) were below the Investors MMA's (intermediate terms). If you are looking to run with trending stocks, you might want to read up on Guppy MMA (Google it. Well worth it). Also, ADX helps with identifying if the stock is trending, but not which direction. Using those three, you can avoid alot of mistakes and up your win ratio.

Another thing is that if you are a firm fundamentalist - that is, buying stocks on their financials, then a 6-day trade is counterintuitive. You should be holding long, and always protect yourself with limits and stops.

 

My 2c.

I'm more prone to technicals myself.

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

Xlthos

Member since: Jun 08

5 Day -8.64%
15 Day 10.44%
1 Month 7.49%
3 Month -0.88%
6 Month -16.94%
As of: 12/02/08
Trades 13
Trade Notes 13
Blog Posts 0
Xlthos
hello,

I have been gone from the market for quite a while and re-entered recently and than found your comment to me...

I have a question:
is there anywhere on line to get Guppy MMA charts or do you have to make them yourself...

Thanks
The content and stock or option symbols on this page are for educational and informational purposes only and should not be considered a recommendation or solicitation to invest in a particular security or type of security. Your use of the TradeKing Community is conditioned to your acceptance of all TradeKing Disclosures and of the TradeKing Community Terms of Service. © 2008 TradeKing.
Testimonials may not be representative of the experience of other clients and are not indicative of future performance or success.