amer3000 > Blogs

User Avatar
Brokerage Account
5 Day 3.44%
15 Day -2.00%
1 Month 1.25%
3 Month 6.34%
6 Month 16.32%
1 Year 20.81%
As of: 11/06/09
How is this calculated?

Member since: Apr 07

Why invest before paying off auto-loan?

I wrote this on my personal blog, I though it would be good to share here since it is related investements and finance.

Yesterday, I talked about how I was going to save and invest most of my income. Some of my friends asked me why not pay off my car first. So I did some calculations. My car loan is at 7.69% interest. My savings APR is 3.49% at HSBCDirect. And I am expecting 8-10% return on my investments in long run.

Based on some rough estimates, I can payoff my auto loan in 10 months. I will save $1,400 in interest. I will have $5,000 less in my savings, $5,000 less in regular investments, and $5,000 less in IRA. My net worth wont change much with either option.

Based on interest and return rates, it is clear that I am better off by investing with expected return rate of 8%. However, I am not really saving money in my saving account. Then on the flip side, the security and peace of mind that liquid asset provides has a lot of value too.

After some thinking I have decided to cut savings by 96% and double my car payments each month. By doing so, I will save $1,000 in interest and payoff my loan in 20 months. I will have $8,000 less in my savings. So in order to recover lost savings I will have to save extra $400 for 20 months after I finish car payments.

 *Please note that this is just my situation. Everyone's situation will be different.

Share This! Report

Posted by amer3000 on 03/04/08 at 04:07 AM

Tag It | 1 user tagged it: Loan, Investment

Comments

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

UPod

Member since: Dec 07

5 Day 6.11%
15 Day -0.73%
1 Month 1.46%
3 Month 9.42%
6 Month 32.80%
1 Year 65.21%
As of: 11/06/09
How is this calculated?
Trades 101
Trade Notes 21
Blog Posts 83
Programmer / Analyst
Age: 30's
Minneapolis, MN
UPod
I don't disagree with your plan, but did you take into consideration that by diverting money from savings towards your car payment, in addition to having $8000 less in your savings, you're also reducing your compounding interest.