Forum > commission structure?
User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

chartman

Member since: May 08

Trades Not Shared
Trade Notes 0
Blog Posts 0

Age: 40's
chartman Brokerage Account

Hello, could someone tell me how many times you pay a commission on a single trade? I recently prepaired my first ever oto  order only to see two $4.95 commissions, one for the buy/stop/limit side and one for the sell/stop side for a total $9.90 commision on 1 trade. Is this normal or specific to conditional orders? Also is this how all brokerages do it? Always thought $4.95 meant buy stock, hold into profit, then sell, one price. How does it work? Thanks in advance

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

FoolMBA

Member since: May 08

Trades Not Shared
Trade Notes 0
Blog Posts 0
FoolMBA Brokerage Account

The  4.95 is per ORDER not per round trip. Each round trip has a minimum of two ORDERS a BUY and a SELL.   If your oder is filled in more than one lot it is still considered just one trade. For instance the last stock I bought 100 shares of  got filled in 2 lots one of 42 share then a second of 58, this was still a single BUY order.  Also if I take profits on  part of the stock.. say it doubles and I Sell half to get my investment out. That will mean that I will eventaually have 3 Orders for this stock One BUY and two SELL orders once teh postion is liquidated.

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

stangracin

Member since: Jun 07

5 Day 0.00%
15 Day 0.00%
1 Month 0.00%
3 Month -93.08%
6 Month -99.44%
As of: 10/05/08
Trades 155
Trade Notes 4
Blog Posts 52
BPM Technical Consultant / Software Architect
Age: 20's
Yorkville, IL
stangracin Brokerage Account

In addition, what FoolMBA describes is indeed normal & is also how all the other brokerages do it. You go to any other site, their commission fees are the same way, just more $!

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

chartman

Member since: May 08

Trades Not Shared
Trade Notes 0
Blog Posts 0

Age: 40's
chartman Brokerage Account

Thanks guys, this only comfirms my decision to move my acc from Fidelity where trades would have been $20 ($40) round trip. Thought I was saving $15, turns out i'm saving $30 per trade. And big thanks to Tradeking !!

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

SF

Member since: May 08

Trades Not Shared
Trade Notes 0
Blog Posts 0

Age: 20's
FL
SF Brokerage Account

Since we're discussing commissions, I've been wondering something myself. If I were to use all my available funds on a trade (leaving my account balance under $4.95) - When I go to sell the stock/option will TK deduct the commission from the proceeds of the trade or does the commission need to be available in the account when you are making the sale?

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

rauchcory

Member since: Jan 08

Trades 52
Trade Notes 12
Blog Posts 1
rauchcory Brokerage Account

it'll be deducted from the sale

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

TampaJake

Member since: Mar 08

Trades 50
Trade Notes 0
Blog Posts 0
TampaJake Brokerage Account

REGARDING PARTIAL FILLS >>>> HERE is something that happened to me. I was entering a covered call trade for 3 contracts and decided to edit my debit. The order partially filled prior to the edit (even though it was not showing on my summary at the time). When I went back to check for an  execution the entire order had filled but I was charged 2 commissions at $4.95 plus the option contracts. Contacted TK and they refunded the second $4.95 commission. I am a new trader and was unaware of this scenario at the time. The rep said if I had not edited the debit this would not have occured, even with the partial fill.

I would suppose if you edit a buy order for stock and the order partially filled and then you edited the buy price the same would occur.

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

stangracin

Member since: Jun 07

5 Day 0.00%
15 Day 0.00%
1 Month 0.00%
3 Month -93.08%
6 Month -99.44%
As of: 10/05/08
Trades 155
Trade Notes 4
Blog Posts 52
BPM Technical Consultant / Software Architect
Age: 20's
Yorkville, IL
stangracin Brokerage Account

TampaJake,

 You are correctt, for a partial fill order, the commission is charged on the very first transaction. If after that point, you change the order, essentially it becomes a new order at that point, and thus a second commission is charged. That was nice of TK to refund the $4.95 as a gesture of goodwill!

 

 

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

bellins1

Member since: Jun 08

5 Day -9.79%
15 Day -30.17%
1 Month -29.89%
3 Month -51.50%
6 Month N/A
As of: 10/05/08
Trades 51
Trade Notes 6
Blog Posts 0

Age: 30's
bellins1 Brokerage Account

Here's something I don't understand (my first order with TK) : I'm doing a "one triggers the other" Option order >> buy 1 option to open, $5.60, then sell 1 option to close, $5.60 (total=11.20) . So, why does the est order total = $21.21 ?  (I'm trying to buy an option with a limit order, then sell with a STOP it if it goes in the wrong direction).

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

RetireOnTime

Member since: Dec 07

Trades Not Shared
Trade Notes 0
Blog Posts 1
RetireOnTime Brokerage Account

Are you counting the cost of the contract x100?  You pay the commission ($4.95), the price per contract ($0.65) and the cost per share of the contract x 100 shares.

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

bellins1

Member since: Jun 08

5 Day -9.79%
15 Day -30.17%
1 Month -29.89%
3 Month -51.50%
6 Month N/A
As of: 10/05/08
Trades 51
Trade Notes 6
Blog Posts 0

Age: 30's
bellins1 Brokerage Account

For example(one triggers other) this is what my preview screen shows:

Order #1 Buy to Open 1 $5.60 $165.60 C TR C Aug 2008 17.5 Put Limit 1.60 Day None

Order #2 Sell to Close 1 $5.60 $174.39 C TR C Aug 2008 17.5 Put Stop 1.80 Good Til Cancel None

Commission: $11.20
SEC Fee: $0.01
Estimated Order Total: $8.79

I don't understand why the est total order is $8.79 and not $165.60 + $174.39 + comm of $11.20? And also, is this how a "one triggers the other" works? I can't watch it during the day but want to buy at 1.60 then sell for a profit if the option premium goes up to say, $1.80.. And if this isn't a good way to make this order, what would a better process be? Thanks.
 

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

RetireOnTime

Member since: Dec 07

Trades Not Shared
Trade Notes 0
Blog Posts 1
RetireOnTime Brokerage Account

OK, you're paying $160 for option on C plus $5.60 for the commission - your total here is $165.60.

Next you're selling a contract on C for $180 minus your $5.60 commission and minus the $.01 SEC fee, so you are receiving a credit of $174.39.  When you subtract $165.60 (bought Cfrom your $174.39 credit you are receiving a net credit of $8.79, that is money credited to your account for selling order #2. 

User Avatar
User Avatar TradeKing Staff Member

Chris L

Member since: Sep 07

Trades Not Shared
Trade Notes 0
Blog Posts 0
Stock Broker
Age: 20's
Charlotte, NC UNITED STATES
Chris L TradeKing Staff Member

Hey everyone!

First off let me say thanks to everyone for all the great answers that have been given in this thread.  That is what this community is all about; people helping other people become more savvy and educated investors.  I want to clarify a few things that have been discussed in this thread to make sure everyone is clear on how our commissions operate.

1. Partial Fills - We charge one commission for any partial fills that execute over the course of the same day.  If you change your order or the order takes multiple days to execute, you will be charged a new commission for each day a partial order executes or for each changed/new order you create.

2. OTO Commissions - Because an OTO order consists of two orders, you will be charged two commissions.  Please remember though that you are only charged a commission once an order has executed.  We will never charge you a commission for an order that never executes.

3. Estimated Order Total - RetireOnTime explained this just as I would have.  The Est. Order Total is either the net credit or debit, including all fees and commissions, that occurs in your account when your order(s) execute.

Hope this adds a little clarity to all the questions in this thread. Give us a buzz at 877-495-5464 if anyone has any account specific questions.  Thanks everyone!

Chris Lebhar
TradeKing Customer Service Representative

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

RetireOnTime

Member since: Dec 07

Trades Not Shared
Trade Notes 0
Blog Posts 1
RetireOnTime Brokerage Account

Sorry folks - I was still clarifying my post when work got me distracted and I just submitted earlier. I wish I oculd edit to fix what was left out!

I wrote: 

"When you subtract $165.60 (bought Cfrom your $174.39 credit you are receiving a net credit of $8.79, that is money credited to your account for selling order #2 "

 

I wanted to be clear and write:

"When you subtract $165.60 (bought C) from your $174.39 credit  (sold C) you are receiving a net credit of $8.79, that is money credited to your account for selling order #2"

 

Not a big difference, but it drove me crazy when I tried to read my post.

 

Thanks for the info on orders Chris, although that was the expected behavior, it's nice to have it "in writing". 

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

bellins1

Member since: Jun 08

5 Day -9.79%
15 Day -30.17%
1 Month -29.89%
3 Month -51.50%
6 Month N/A
As of: 10/05/08
Trades 51
Trade Notes 6
Blog Posts 0

Age: 30's
bellins1 Brokerage Account

Thanks a lot everyone for posting and responding to my question. You've cleared up the OTO's quite a bit for me. Didn't even think about it as being the net difference between the two orders.

On my other brokerage acct, I was used to logical orders for buying with a limit, then selling if the price went above this level or below that level. That would have been two commissions also, one on each side. From what I see so far, I could do a Contingent order to BUY then SELL at either "above" or "below", but not both. That was with stock trades though, not options. TK is still a much more robust trading acct. Thanks again for all your help!!

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

SF

Member since: May 08

Trades Not Shared
Trade Notes 0
Blog Posts 0

Age: 20's
FL
SF Brokerage Account

Regarding what Chris said about partial fills:

Assume I am putting an order in for multiple contracts, on a lower volume option (like not in the hundreds/thousands), and not at the ask price - should I always place these orders AON to avoid partial fills over multiple days?

Also, if I were to roll the dice and not put it in as AON and only got a partial fill - Would the order automatically still be in effect the next day (even if it wasn't GTC) because it was only partially filled?

Just looking for elaboration on partial fills regarding multiple days and the best way to avoid multiple commissions if anyone can help on that. Thank you.

User Avatar
User Avatar TradeKing Staff Member

irishneal11

Member since: Oct 05

Trades Not Shared
Trade Notes 0
Blog Posts 0
stock broker
Age: 30's
Boca Raton, FL UNITED STATES
irishneal11 TradeKing Staff Member

Good Morning SF:
AON is an alternative to avoid split and partial fills, however that does also make it harder for the order to be executed. This is particularly problematic when dealing with an options without much liquidity. If you place a day order which is partially filled, the unfilled portion of the order would expire at the close of business on the day it was placed. The decision to weigh when considering whether or not to use AON, is the possibility of not being filled at all worth the cost of the possible extra commission you may incur if you do not qualify the order as AON.
Regards
Neal Atkins- TRADEKING -Supervisor E-Communications

User Avatar
User Avatar Brokerage Account

SF

Member since: May 08

Trades Not Shared
Trade Notes 0
Blog Posts 0

Age: 20's
FL
SF Brokerage Account

That's pretty much how I figured it worked out in the end. More or less just have to weigh each order individually and decide if a split/partial fill was worth more than not getting a fill at all.

Thanks Neal, it is much appreciated.