Cash-Secured Puts

Posted by kenlee17 on May 07, 2008 (03:36PM)

I'm trying to execute this strategy: https://www.tradeking.com/PrivateView/edu/opb/opbSellingCashPutsStockBuy.tmpl

The option I'm trying to sell is DZG QB, when I enter a "Sell to Close" order, Tradeking tells me: "Execution of this trade may create a naked option position. Your account is not authorized for this level of options trading."  What am I doing wrong?

BTW, I have a Level 1 options trading account.  

Posted by Ivan Boesky on May 08, 2008 (06:52AM)

Well to start out. It would be a "Sell to Open" trade, not a "sell to close".

And #2, you need level 4 trading in order to sell cash secured puts. 

Posted by kenlee17 on May 08, 2008 (08:34AM)

Ah, thank you for letting me know, Ivan.  I thought basic Level 1/2 options trading would work for this as it was listed under the "Rookies Strategies" page.

Posted by Buffett Wannabe on May 19, 2008 (01:48PM)

> And #2, you need level 4 trading in order to sell cash secured puts Just to clarify... It seems to me that Level IV trading is only needed for "unsecured" (naked) put writing, not "cash secured" put writing. Why would a cash secured put possibly require Level IV, particularly when it is considered as relatively "safe" an option play as possible? Thanks.

Posted by Potaire on May 19, 2008 (02:38PM)

NOTE: Cash-secured puts can be executed by investors at any level. See the "Rookie's Corner" for a more in-depth explanation of this play.   WHEN TO RUN IT

You're slightly bearish short-term; bullish long-term.

Potaire

 

Posted by Potaire on May 19, 2008 (02:41PM)

Above copied from the Playbook.  But, "Sell to Close" would definately gum it all up, as Ivan said.

Potaire

Posted by EnglishTeach on May 19, 2008 (03:05PM)

The note on "investors at any level" refers to the level of experience, not the options trading level.  Good luck!

Posted by kenlee17 on May 20, 2008 (03:56AM)

I am also approved for options trading at TD Ameritrade.  TD Ameritrade states that:

"A cash-secured put is a short put option position where the writer (seller) also holds cash in his or her account equal to the amount of money that would be needed to satisfy the writer's obligation should the option(s) be assigned. In order to write cash-secured puts, your account must have Covered (Level 1) options approval."

I'm just curious as to why I can't do this here at TradeKing, when I can do it with a Level 1 approval with TDAM.

 

Posted by Potaire on May 20, 2008 (04:16AM)

I just asked Chris (staff) in Live Help---Level IV is required.  Ivan and the Teacher are correct--the rest of us are wrong.  Chris says TK is trying to get the clearing house to ease up a bit on this restriction.

Potaire

Posted by irishneal11 on May 20, 2008 (09:56AM)

Good Afternoon Everyone:


We actually require Level 4 in order to write a put, whether it's cash secured or being held on margin. Strictly from a strategy and option knowledge level point of view the risk is still the same. Our clearing firm considers this strategy a more advanced strategy which would require some option trading experience, and other requirements prior to trading. They hold all put writing activity to a Level 4 approval, whether naked or covered. Also, another thing to consider is the risk to reward ratio. For example if you are buying puts or calls to open, the max loss would be the premium and with a call your potential gain is infinite. However when writing a put, you are putting up a lot of money, some people do this to collect premiums while others do it because they evenually want to own the stock. So they are a bit more complex from that standpoint.
While the fact that the position is cash covered does lower TradeKing\'s risk, the risk to the client remains the same, the difference between the Strike price and the Premium received.

Regards
Neat Atkins - Supervisor E-Communications - TradeKing

Posted by EnglishTeach on May 23, 2008 (08:33AM)

A good rule of thumb is to ask yourself if you are willing (no matter what) to own the specific stock at the specific price.  So if you sell a June $120 put for RIMM @ 2.0 credit (today's prices), then you should be willing to own 100 shares of RIMM for $120 even if the price plummets to $110.

 

You might could see it as a way to set a limit buy order and get paid a premium to do so.   So...  sell a $120 June put on RIMM, receive $200, keep $12,000 cash in your account until expiration and you will own the stock for $120/share if it falls that much (which I doubt this month).

 

...(if I'm understanding this correctly)  ;P

Posted by Ivan Boesky on May 23, 2008 (11:48AM)

Selling puts is easy money. IMO it's a much better strategy than covered calls.

Posted by Buffett Wannabe on June 12, 2008 (09:14AM)

I agree with EnglishTeach.  If one is willing to lock up the cash, then covered put selling should be available at any trade level.  It seems like this is more of a software function/problem to ensure that the client has the cash available to secure the put's strike price.  Again, if TD and others can do it for Level 1, so can TK.

You must Log In to post to this forum.

Not a member? Register Now to …

  • See what other traders are doing
  • Make your own trades public
  • Share your thoughts on a trade
  • Join or start a group
  • Connect with like-minded traders